Dear Xenia
I get it. I really do. By your own admission, you spent over a year on this ‘Chinadoll’ concept and now you don’t want to see all that effort go down the drain. I understand that you’re upset that the picture you envisioned; the words you have written, have been taken as an insult and as offensive. I get that in a perfect world, everyone would just see it the way you do, as a work of art and evocative of a fantasy that was never really true. I sympathise, truly I do – that every precious individual in fact has opinions of their own instead, opinions based on their life, experiences and education. I’m ever so sorry that this means they have every right to be upset with you, Xenia.
I bitch about my life often. Who doesn’t? I moan about the little slights in my life, areas of my world that might improve if only… Well, the end of that varies in the telling. But not thing I have never had to complain about is being subjugated. You see, I am a white woman, living in the developed world – with a home, food in my cupboards and money in the bank. I have never needed to struggle too hard, even when I was homeless, or suffered through several bouts of severe depression. I got help, through the system of this country, and got back on track. My life is not a sad story. I have survived these things, and I am proud of that, but I realise things would have been different if I were darker skinned, if I were raised in poorer country, or yes, if I were Chinese.
You see Xenia, if I were Chinese, I would hear “I give you 5 dollah, sucky sucky, you love me long time?”, by idiots who can’t differentiate between Chinese people and Vietnamese character in a movie. I would be laughed at for having ‘squinty eyes’. People would yell at me, thinking I don’t understand English, volume of course being the universal translator. Some might assume I work in a takeaway and tell me I reek of curry, even if I don’t. People might even poke fun at my mother tongue, saying nonsense words that sound Chinapanese.
At school, I had a friend who went through that, and more – EVERY SINGLE DAY. No matter that she was born and raised in Scotland, spoke with a Scottish accent, had short hair and told the best dirty jokes – she was expected to be this fragile, silent caricature of herself, complete with a ‘funny’ accent, long hair and a permissive demeanour. And this was from KIDS. Kids that, as soon as it was common knowledge, expected lil perfect chinadoll Ling to be a WHORE. A tigress in bed. And believe me, kids are cruel. Especially to one not their *own*. I was bullied for being a goth. She was TERRORISED for being something she had absolutely no control over. It was because of who she was, and what she wasn’t.
Why am I telling you this Xenia? Simply because, as a woman of white privilege, you will never understand how it feels to have some stranger build an entire image of how they expect you to behave before you even open your mouth to speak. You will never know what it is to battle against attitudes and stereotypes that were antiquated even before you were born, because people can’t be bothered to learn that there is more to you than your skin colour.
You’ve been accused of being a mail order bride, haven’t you Xenia? It sucked, didn’t it, to have someone assume that of you? I bet you’ve heard all sorts of vodka jokes, or that you’re a commie. Some people might have been down right hateful, just because of your accent. I know when I speak to non-Scottish people, I’m told I eat deep fried mars bars, that I’m violent, or I must drink a lot. I have people shouting FRREEEDDOOMM! at me so much I’d gladly punch Mel Gibson until his head exploded. Hmm. Maybe there’s a grain of truth up there. My point is, it blows. But I’d still take this over the blatant racism people of colour face.
Back in school, when Ling told the teachers about how the other kids treated her, they did not say, “get on with it”. They took it seriously because if they didn’t, not only would they have been allowing that sort of racial stereotype to grow into acceptance in the minds of children, they would have been fired. They did not tell her it was only a harmless fantasy, and that the imagery of a subservent Chinese women who whored it up in bed was beautiful. No Xenia, they rounded up the kids and doled out punishment to those who continuously forced the racial abuse. As white adults, they knew their responsibility lay in supporting Ling and her culture, a real, evolving, beautiful person and her rich and wonderful heritage.
Have I mentioned yet, I love researching the history of the Geisha? Its true, I often discuss with friends the different stories I have read about the art form, the lifestyle, and how the entire culture is expected to survive in these modern times. I wear my hair up in chopsticks, one of the few ways my mop stays put. My Love, a white man, learned how to make sushi. Aside from that, I adore Bollywood movies and used to wear a bindi going out. I made great friends with the man who sold them to me, who thought it so amusing that I loved them so much and wore them dancing. One day I want to learn flamenco dance. I think this world, this tiny world is so fascinating, so beautifully diverse and colourful, and I want to experience and cherish everything that it can offer. The minute however, I am told I am disrespectful, I would stop whatever I was doing and make amends. No questions. I would defer to the right of a person to defend their culture and try to learn more about what I did wrong to ensure I wouldn’t do it again. Learning, some might say. I suppose its easy to say that now, having not offended anyone (that I know of, mind you) – but this incident has made me more sure than ever of the right thing to do. I’ll give you a hint. It’s not what you just done.
The funny thing is, not much would have had to have changed. You could have even got more models of different cultures, a la Benetton, to wear your make up. You needn’t have even changed the names of the eye shadows, some thought they were laughable but I haven’t seen anyone say they were offensive. The stickler, as they say, was the text accompanying it. Highlight it. CTRL x. Gone. Say, I didn’t intend for my words to be offensive, and I’m glad to learn more about cultural appropriation and how we, as a company, can fight against racism on any level. I hope our fans and supporters have also learned something positive from this exchange, and we can move forward with better understanding and an open dialogue. Wearing Lime Crime and having intelligent discourse y’all!
(you can keep that by the way.)
Sadly, you’re stubborn. Frankly, I’ve seen better apologises from my 4 year old niece and that girl doesn’t like being wrong! This wasn’t an apology, it was an excuse. And worse, a dismissal. Like it or not? Seriously, THAT’S what you’re saying to potential customers? Well Xenia, like it or not – no Disney movie is going to justify your monumental fuck up. All because you refused to learn. Sorry princess. This is the really real world. The unicorn is just a horse and you are just a petulant child. You’ve just proved that.
Regards




















